In a ruling in December, French court held the use of P2P networks as legal as long as it was for personal and not commercial use, it included both downloading and uploading of copyrighted files. SCPP, a producer association in 2004 had sued Anthony G. for downloading and uploading 1,212 music tracks over Kazaa. Court held these acts of downloading and uploading qualified as "private copying". Also French Parliament is in the process of discussing whether P2P use should be legalized.